Back to Blog
Legal Guides

Workers' Comp vs. Personal Injury: Can You File Both?

AD

Alicia Dawson

November 22, 2024 6 min read
Workers' Comp vs. Personal Injury: Can You File Both?

Overview Summary

  • 1Workers' Comp pays bills/wages regardless of fault but bars you from suing your boss.
  • 2Personal Injury claims require proving fault but offer 'pain and suffering' damages (which Comp doesn't).
  • 3Third-Party Claims: You CAN sue a negligent third party (like a delivery driver or machine manufacturer) while collecting Comp.
  • 4You often make more money by filing both claims simultaneously.
  • 5Workers' Comp has a lien on your settlement; a lawyer negotiates this down.

If you are hurt on the job, you file Workers' Comp. But what if someone else caused the injury? You might be leaving millions on the table by not filing a Personal Injury lawsuit too.

The 'Exclusive Remedy' Rule

You generally cannot sue your employer for negligence. Workers' Comp is your 'exclusive remedy.' It's a trade-off: you get guaranteed benefits without proving fault, but you give up the right to sue.

The Third-Party Loophole

However, if a third party (not your employer/coworker) hurt you, you can sue them. Examples:

  • A delivery driver hits you while you are driving a company van.
  • A subcontractor drops a tool on your head at a construction site.
  • A machine you are using malfunctions due to a manufacturing defect.

In these cases, you get Workers' Comp benefits immediately AND sue the third party for pain and suffering.

Saad Admani

About the Author

Saad Admani is the lead Personal Injury Attorney at Admani Law with extensive experience representing accident victims in NJ. He specializes in fighting insurance claims, negotiating settlements, and advocating passionately for his clients.

Call 24/7
    Workers Comp Vs Personal Injury | Car Injury Law Blog